Blog > Sheet Vinyl vs. LVP and LVT: Which Is Best for Your Home in PA?

Sheet Vinyl vs. LVP and LVT: Which Is Best for Your Home in PA?

Monday, July 07, 2025

What’s the Difference Between Sheet Vinyl, LVP & LVT?

Choosing new flooring can feel like walking into a maze of options. Sheet Vinyl, LVP, LVT—it’s enough to make your head spin, right?

At Nolt’s Floor Covering, we’ve been helping local homeowners in Ephrata, Myerstown, and across Lancaster and Lebanon Counties pick the perfect flooring for decades. And we get this question all the time:

“What’s the difference between Sheet Vinyl, LVP, and LVT?”

So today, we’re breaking it down for you—casually, clearly, and without the salesy jargon. Because that’s what neighbors do.

First Things First: What Are They?

Let’s clear up what we’re talking about here:

Sheet Vinyl

• Sold in large rolls
• Seamless, waterproof surface
• Great for bathrooms, laundry rooms, and basements

We installed sheet vinyl in a farmhouse mudroom just outside Lititz. The homeowner has dogs, several grandkids, and a garden that never sleeps. She is THRILLED that she can mop it clean in seconds.

LVP (Luxury Vinyl Plank)

• Plank-shaped pieces that look like hardwood
• Click-together or glue-down install
• Durable, scratch-resistant, stylish

One of our employees Brian put LVP in his own Lebanon home—and it’s held up beautifully. The floors still look brand new years later.

LVT (Luxury Vinyl Tile)

• Square pieces that mimic stone or ceramic
• Softer underfoot than real tile
• Often installed with or without grout

One customer from Myerstown picked a slate-look LVT for her powder room and it fooled everyone, including her mother-in-law, who swore it was real tile!

Quick Comparison Table:

Pros & Cons – Based on Real Homes in Central PA

Sheet Vinyl – Great for Budget & Moisture

Pros:

• One solid, waterproof surface
• Less expensive, especially for large areas
• Great in damp areas like basements or mudrooms

Cons:

• Tougher to patch or repair
• Not ideal if you want a high-end look
• May need more sub-floor preparation or ¼” underlayment

Pro tip: If your basement floods often, sheet vinyl could save you from having to replace planks or tiles every rainy season.

LVP – Looks Like Wood

Pros:

• Beautiful hardwood looks without worry
• DIY-friendly
• Scratch-resistant and durable

Cons:

• Slightly more expensive than sheet vinyl

LVT – The Stylish Show-Off

Pros:

• Realistic tile or stone visuals
• Soft and warm underfoot
• Perfect for kitchens or guest bathrooms

Cons:

• Layout and install take more effort

True story: A homeowner in Lebanon told us her guests were blown away by her “stone” floors—and she was equally thrilled that she could stand barefoot on them while cooking without freezing her toes off.

Which Vinyl Is Right for Your PA Home?

Here’s the quick cheat sheet:

• For busy families: Go with LVP for the best balance of looks and performance.
• For high-moisture or low-use areas: Try sheet vinyl—easy to clean and budget-friendly.
• For stylish spaces or bathrooms: Choose LVT for that “wow” factor without the cold feel of real tile.

We’re not just guessing here—we’ve installed every option in homes all over Lancaster County and Lebanon County. We know what holds up to local weather, PA basements, and muddy boots.

Local Flooring Advice You Can Trust

Here in Central Pennsylvania, we get:

• Four distinct seasons (hello, humidity)
• Wet winters and muddy springs
• Families with busy lifestyles

That means your floors need to work hard while still looking good. We help customers weigh all those local factors when making their choice.

Why Nolt’s Floor Covering?

We’re not a chain. We’re your neighbors—and we treat your home like it’s our own.

• Family-owned and operated
• Trusted in the Ephrata and Myerstown communities
• Full service: from advice to install to follow-up
• Huge selection of vinyl flooring you can see and touch in person

“We believe in making your flooring dreams come true.”

That’s not just a tagline—it’s how we’ve run our business for decades.

Ready to Explore Sheet Vinyl, LVP, or LVT?

Stop by our Ephrata or Myerstown showroom and see the difference for yourself. Whether you’re remodeling a bathroom, updating a rental, or building your forever home, we’ll help you find a floor that fits your needs and budget—without the pressure.

➡️ Stop by our showrooms in Ephrata or Myerstown to see these stunning floors in person

📍 Ephrata, PA– 609 North State St., Ephrata PA 17522 (717) 733-5503
📍 Myerstown, PA– 400 West Lincoln Ave., Myerstown PA 17067 (717) 866-6186

Or schedule a free in-home consultation — we’ll bring the samples to you!

Let’s find the perfect floor for your home — and make your flooring dreams come true!

Happy flooring – Nolt’s Floor Covering

Making your flooring dreams come true!