Blog > Lancaster and Lebanon County’s Most Popular Hardwood Flooring Choices for 2025

Lancaster and Lebanon County’s Most Popular Hardwood Flooring Choices for 2025

Tuesday, September 02, 2025

When you step into a home, one of the first things you notice is the flooring. It sets the tone for the entire space — cozy, modern, rustic, or timeless. And here in Lancaster and Lebanon County, one flooring choice continues to stand the test of time: hardwood.

At Nolt’s Floor Covering, with locations in Ephrata and Myerstown, we’ve helped hundreds of homeowners and business owners choose hardwood floors that transform their spaces. From farmhouse renovations in Lititz to new builds in Myerstown and stylish office upgrades in Lebanon, hardwood remains one of the most popular choices for 2025 — and for good reason.

Why Hardwood Flooring Remains a Top Choice for PA Homes

Hardwood flooring has been around for centuries, and yet it never feels outdated. The reason is simple: it combines timeless beauty with lasting durability.

Benefits Homeowners Love

• Adds warmth and character – Whether you’re working with oak, maple, or hickory, hardwood brings a natural charm you just can’t replicate with synthetic materials.
• Boosts home value – Real estate agents in Lancaster and Lebanon agree: homes with hardwood floors tend to sell faster and for higher prices.
• Built to last – A well-installed hardwood floor can last 50+ years with proper care.
• Design flexibility – Today’s options range from rustic wide-plank oak to sleek modern finishes, meaning you can match any décor.

Here’s a personal example: we helped a family in Manheim Township replace worn-out carpet in their living room with natural white oak planks. When we returned a few months later to install hardwood in their kitchen, the homeowner told us, “I had no idea how much brighter and bigger our living room would feel — it’s like we moved into a brand-new house!”

Trending Hardwood Styles Lancaster and Lebanon Homeowners Love

Every year, we see shifts in hardwood flooring preferences. In 2025, three trends are leading the way among Lancaster and Lebanon County homeowners:

Rustic Oak

Rustic Oak hardwood is one of the hottest flooring styles this year. Homeowners are drawn to its open, seamless look and the natural variations in grain and color that make each plank unique.

Why it’s popular locally:

• Perfect for Lancaster County’s farmhouse-style homes.
• Adds warmth and texture without feeling overly rustic.
• Wider boards make small rooms appear larger and more open.

Just a few months ago, we installed 4 ¼”-inch rustic oak planks in a one-story farmhouse outside Lititz. The boards had knots and natural character that gave the home a lived-in, welcoming feel. The homeowner told us, “It looks like these floors have been part of the house forever.” That’s the magic of rustic hardwood — it feels both timeless and fresh.

Modern Matte Finishes

High-gloss hardwood used to be a status symbol, but in 2025, homeowners are leaning toward matte and satin finishes. These finishes create a soft, modern vibe and are easier to maintain — especially in busy households.

Why we recommend matte finishes:

• Hides scratches and footprints better than shiny finishes.
• Ideal for families with kids and pets.
• Works beautifully in open-concept homes for a more natural look.

For example, we worked with a family in Ephrata who chose light maple hardwood with a matte finish for their entire first floor. The result? A bright, airy space that requires little upkeep.

Engineered Hardwood for Stability

While solid hardwood remains popular, engineered hardwood has grown into a top seller here in Lancaster and Lebanon County. Why? It’s more resistant to moisture and temperature changes, making it perfect for our Pennsylvania climate.

Where engineered hardwood shines:

• Basements and lower levels – Less prone to warping in humid spaces.
• Kitchens and dining rooms – Withstands spills and daily traffic.
• Commercial spaces – Durable enough for heavy foot traffic without sacrificing style.

Our store in Ephrata we used engineered Brazilian Oak flooring for part of our showroom. After two years of customers coming and going, the floors still look brand new. That’s the kind of reliability busy business owners love.

Comparing Engineered vs. Solid Hardwood

When choosing hardwood flooring, one of the first decisions you’ll make is whether to go with solid hardwood or engineered hardwood. At Nolt’s, we help homeowners weigh the pros and cons based on lifestyle, budget, and long-term plans.

Pro Tip: Many of our customers mix the two in their homes. For example, we often recommend solid hardwood for main living spaces where you want maximum longevity, and engineered hardwood for lower levels or rooms prone to moisture.

Hardwood Flooring Trends for Commercial Spaces

It’s not just homeowners in Lancaster and Lebanon who are embracing hardwood — commercial spaces are, too. More small businesses, boutique shops, and office spaces are switching from vinyl or carpet to engineered hardwood because it:

• Withstands heavy foot traffic
• Creates a high-end, polished look
• Is easier to clean and maintain

We’ve recently completed installs for a few local businesses, including a professional office in Lebanon and a jewelry store in Manhiem. Both owners told us the same thing: hardwood transformed their spaces and elevated their customers’ first impressions.

Nolt’s Floor Covering — Making Your Flooring Dreams Come True!

Choosing the right hardwood flooring can feel overwhelming, but that’s where we come in. At Nolt’s Floor Covering, we’re a local, family-owned business serving Lancaster and Lebanon County for years.

When you work with us, you get:

• Personalized consultations – We listen to your goals, your style, and your budget.
• Expert installation – Our team treats every project as if it’s their own home.
• Local expertise – We understand the unique styles of Lancaster and Lebanon homes and businesses.
• Latest hardwood trends – From rustic oak to engineered hickory, we carry the top styles for 2025.

If you’re ready to explore the most popular hardwood flooring choices in Lancaster and Lebanon PA, visit one of our showrooms in Ephrata or Myerstown.

📍 Ephrata, PA– 609 North State St., Ephrata PA 17522 (717) 733-5503

📍 Myerstown, PA– 400 West Lincoln Ave., Myerstown PA 17067 (717) 866-6186

➡️ Or schedule a free consultation — we’ll bring the samples to you!

Happy flooring – Nolt’s Floor Covering - Making your flooring dreams come true!