Blog > Best Flooring to Increase Home Value in Lancaster & Lebanon County, PA

Best Flooring to Increase Home Value in Lancaster & Lebanon County, PA

Monday, February 02, 2026

If you’re a homeowner in Lancaster County or Lebanon County, there’s one upgrade that consistently boosts your home’s value more than almost any other new flooring.

At Nolt’s Floor Covering in Ephrata and Myerstown, PA, we walk through homes every week with sellers, realtors, and homeowners getting ready to list. And time after time, we see the same thing:

Homes with updated flooring sell faster, receive stronger offers, and face fewer inspection negotiations.

If you’re wondering what is the best flooring for home value in PA, this guide will walk you through the smartest choices for resale based on what actually works in local Lancaster and Lebanon County homes.

Because at the end of the day, we’re not just selling floors we’re Making your flooring dreams come true!

Nolt’s Floor Covering showroom in Ephrata.

Why Flooring Matters for Home Resale in Pennsylvania

Flooring is one of the most powerful visual and emotional triggers for home buyers. It covers nearly every square foot of your home, which means it immediately sets the tone the moment someone walks inside.

In competitive markets like Lancaster PA, Ephrata, Lititz, Manheim, Lebanon, and Myerstown, buyers are looking for move-in-ready homes not renovation projects.

Here’s why flooring upgrades pay off so well:

1. Buyers Notice Floors First

Clean, modern flooring makes a home feel updated and well-maintained. Old carpet, worn vinyl, or scratched hardwood sends the opposite message even if the rest of the house is in good shape.

2. Outdated Floors Kill Offers

When buyers see old flooring, they immediately think:

• “How much will this cost to replace?”
• “What other issues might there be?”
• “Should I lower my offer?”

New flooring removes those objections.

3. Flooring Delivers One of the Best ROIs

We’ve seen countless Lancaster County homes sell for thousands more after a smart flooring update. One Ephrata homeowner replaced worn carpet and vinyl with luxury vinyl plank and new bedroom carpet and their home sold in four days above asking price.

High-ROI Flooring Options for Pennsylvania Homes

Not all flooring materials perform equally when it comes to resale value. These are the options we recommend most when homeowners ask us how to increase their home’s value.

Hardwood Flooring: The Gold Standard

Hardwood floors remain one of the top resale drivers in Lancaster County and across Pennsylvania.

Buyers love hardwood because it feels:

• Warm
• Premium
• Timeless

Why hardwood adds home value

• Can be refinished multiple times
• Appeals to nearly every buyer
• Works in traditional and modern homes
• Adds instant visual impact

We recently installed engineered hardwood in a Mount Joy home preparing to list. The realtor told us multiple buyers specifically commented on the floors during showings.

Best rooms for hardwood flooring

• Living rooms
• Dining rooms
• Home offices
• Hallways

Engineered Hardwood Flooring in Lititz PA.

Luxury Vinyl Plank: The Best Flooring for Home Value in PA

For many Lancaster and Lebanon County homes, luxury vinyl plank (LVP) is the best flooring investment you can make before selling.

It offers the look of hardwood with far better durability and moisture resistance and it costs less.

Why buyers love luxury vinyl flooring

• Looks like real hardwood or tile
• 100% waterproof
• Scratch and pet resistant
• Lower cost than hardwood
• Fast installation

We install LVP in everything from suburban homes to Lebanon PA medical offices and Lancaster County retail spaces because it performs beautifully while still looking upscale.

One family in Myerstown installed luxury vinyl throughout their main floor before listing — and buyers loved that they didn’t have to worry about kids, pets, or spills.

Best rooms for LVP and LVT

• Kitchens
• Bathrooms
• Laundry rooms
• Basements
• Main living areas

Soft, neutral carpet in a Bird-in-Hand PA home.

Best Flooring for Rental & Commercial Properties

If you own rental homes, offices, or commercial space in Lancaster County or Lebanon County, flooring choices directly affect your property value and tenant satisfaction.

We typically recommend:

• Luxury vinyl plank
• Commercial carpet tile
• Sheet vinyl

These materials offer:

• Durability
• Easy cleaning
• Professional appearance
• Fast replacement

We regularly help landlords and business owners choose flooring that looks great, installs quickly, and holds up to foot traffic.

Commercial flooring in Lancaster PA Church.

Flooring Experts Serving Lancaster & Lebanon County

At Nolt’s Floor Covering, we’ve been helping homeowners, realtors, landlords, and business owners across Ephrata, Myerstown, Lititz, Manheim, Lebanon, and all of Lancaster County and Lebanon County choose the right flooring for decades.

We’re a family-owned, Christian-run flooring store that does it all:

• Measure
• Recommend
• Sell
• Install
• Stand behind every job

Because we install everything we sell, we know exactly what performs best in Pennsylvania homes.

Whether you’re:

• Selling
• Remodeling
• Buying
• Or upgrading a commercial space

We’re here to help you choose flooring that boosts both beauty and home value.

Flooring & Home Value FAQs

What flooring adds the most value to a home in PA?

Hardwood and luxury vinyl plank deliver the best return on investment for most Pennsylvania homes.

Is luxury vinyl better than hardwood for resale?

In many Lancaster and Lebanon County homes, LVP actually performs better because it’s waterproof, scratch-resistant, and budget-friendly while still looking upscale.

What flooring do Lancaster County buyers prefer?

Buyers want modern, neutral flooring that looks clean, durable, and move-in ready especially LVP, hardwood, and new carpet in bedrooms.

How much does new flooring increase home value?

New flooring often returns 70% to 100% of its cost and can lead to faster sales and higher offers.

Get a Free Flooring Consultation

📍Ephrata, PA – 609 N. State St. | (717) 733-5503 

📍Myerstown, PA – 400 W. Lincoln Ave. | (717) 866-6186

Or request a free in-home consultation at:

free-estimate

We’ll bring samples right to your home so you can see what works best in your lighting and space.

Because at the end of the day, we’re not just about floors we’re about Making your flooring dreams come true!